OK, Saddam’s in jail and Iraq is the fifty-first (and best-funded) state. Are we better off than we were a year ago?
Slate‘s Jacob Weisberg asked a prominent group of “liberal hawks” to reassess their support for the war in light of what we now know. While he does not bring up issues relating to the Administration’s morality or mendacity–not to mention the horrible precedent of the world’s only superpower launching an allegedly “preventive” war–Weisberg offers a useful summary of what’s gone wrong from a narrowly pragmatic point of view:
There is “the huge and growing cost of the invasion and occupation: in American lives (we’re about to hit 500 dead and several thousand more have been injured); in money (more than $160 billion in borrowed funds); and in terms of lost opportunity (we might have found Osama Bin Laden by now if we’d committed some of those resources to Afghanistan). Most significant are the least tangible costs: increased hatred for the United States, which both fosters future terrorism and undermines the international support we will need to fight terrorism effectively for many years to come.”
Of the group of eight, Kenneth Pollack, George Packer and Fred Kaplan have all come to regret their previous arguments to various degrees. Pollack, who is a bit equivocal on this point, lays responsibility on his own overestimation of the dictator’s WMD capacity. Fair enough; this was something on which reasonable people could disagree, and as Paul Wolfowitz later admitted, was chosen by the Bush Administration as the focus of its propaganda efforts because of its perceived political potency. Kaplan (who changed his mind before the war began) and Packer lay the blame on the Administration’s postwar incompetence, which, they believe, makes a mockery of the sacrifices it has demanded from this country and from the Iraqis themselves.
The “I’m Still a Hawk” club includes Thomas Friedman, Paul Berman, Christopher Hitchens and Fareed Zakaria. I think we can eliminate Hitchens from the ranks of prowar liberals at the start. As a leftist, he heaped Cockburn-like contempt on liberals; today it’s more of the Horowitzian variety. In either incarnation, he has had little use for Isaiah Berlin or John Dewey. Neither does it make sense to include Fareed Zakaria, who is a protégé of the neoconservative Samuel Huntington (and, like Huntington, a critic of “too much democracy”) and an unrepentant Reaganite. A smart conservative does not a liberal make.
- Nicola Anderson: 'Sorry' seems to be the hardest word in cervical cancer scandal
- 'I'm really sorry': Mark Zuckerberg has been apologising for privacy lapses since before Facebook even began
- Facebook data scandal: Is sorry the hardest word?
- Zuckerberg Tells EU He’s ‘Sorry’ for Facebook’s Privacy Missteps
- 'Anti-Semitism Isn't Prevalent in Labour' , But Present in UK Society
- Report Reveals Global Anti-Semitism Increase Amid Drop in Violence Against Jews
- LESTER: A joy to listen to, a pain in the backside, a man who couldn’t take the emotion out of the game
- When is Elton John’s UK retirement tour? Dates, tickets, prices and venues for the Farewell Yellow Brick Road world tour
- From Elton to Ed: Sir Elton John Tells Young Ed Sheeran Fame Won’t Last
- Who is Antony Costa, when was he in Blue, how much weight did he lose and is he married?
- Upskirting legislation to be adopted as Government Bill
- Plans for upskirting laws welcomed by campaigners
- Weller wows fans at Crathes Concert
- Unpicking Great Northern's apology and explanation for train timetable chaos
- Paisley apologises over rule breach
- John Bercow gets another tennis freebie
- Listen: John McDonnell – ‘we are a party that’s anti-Semitist’
- Live updates from Anthony Joshua vs Joseph Parker fight
- Meet the woman who helps homeless people and their dogs
- Brave mum given months to live 'had cancer symptoms mistaken for pregnancy'
‘Sorry’ Seems to Be the Hardest Word have 630 words, post on www.thenation.com at January 29, 2004. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.